Seriously? Do any of you even think before just plowing ahead full tilt?

[Dean makes a very genuinely disgusted noise, but he doesn't wait:]

The Admiral clearly isn't human. Humans can't do what he promises and what he does. So what is he, then? Where's he getting the power? What good are lost souls to him, and what's he get out of giving you wishes? It ain't out of the goodness of his heart.

Congratulations. You just accepted candy from a goddamn stranger just like you were always told not to.